ATTENDANCE WOES
I will be doing an article on McNeese attendance after all the smoke clears and we have a new coach. In the meantime, there is enough evidence that it is a national problem. ULM and ULL played for a bowl game as well as a spot in the Sun Belt Championship on a beautiful afternoon in Monroe. Coach V was very happy with the turnout, but having watched the game, I would guess there were probably about 15,000 folks there although the announced figure was 18,167. ULL brought a pretty large group as well as their band.
This picture is earlier in the year, but as you can tell they do not use the upper deck much on either side. The Warhawks drew 13,787 for GSU,13,250 for Homecoming, 15,700 for the big Troy game, and 10,137 for the home opener. The 14,200 average this year was a large increase over the 9,988 average in 2017.
The Wall Street Journal called 2017 the worst in recent history. They even went after ULM for having only 26% of their 2017 total attendance scanned. Thus the Warhawks averaged 2660 tickets scanned per game.
Only 71% of the reported announced attendance actually scanned their ticket to enter the stadium. Taking that into consideration, 2017 was the biggest drop in attendance in modern history. Some schools numbers were skewed at an alarming rate. For example, Louisiana Monroe reported a total attendance of 49,640 for their five home games in 2017. However, according to the wall street journal reporting, they only drew 13,302 fans in tickets scanned. That is just a 26% clip of the total attendance.
The folks bringing the LA Tech game said that there were about 7,000 there for the first half and about 3500 after halftime. They were playing 2-9 WKU and fell behind 20-0 which ran off most of the fans. The announced crowd was 11,459 due to a good season ticket base.
The announcers for Texas A&M and LSU said that A&M failed to sell over 10,000 tickets for this game. Also, the Ohio State vs Michigan game fell 6,000 short of a sellout for a game that has been sold out for many years.
I just wanted to mention this now while the radio guys this morning were discussing the drop in attendance. It was a holiday weekend, so there are some circumstances, but the game has lost about 3% annually for a while.
This is an actual photo of the student section at the University of Arkansas for the UNT game in September.
OK, ENOUGH OF THAT. I JUST WANTED TO SET UP THE DISCUSSION FOR AFTER THE HOLIDAYS.
COACHING SEARCH
I know the most interest in chat rooms and forums is on the coaching search. Officially there is no legit information being discussed. It is fun for everybody to throw out names for the administration to look at; but in the end, this search will have to follow state protocol for advertisement and transparency. The job was posted on Monday afternoon. Signing day is December 19.
MCNEESE HAS PUT AN ADVERTISEMENT IN THE NCAA JOB MARKET FOR A HEAD FOOTBALL COACH WITH D1 OR D2 EXPERIENCE AS EITHER A COORDINATOR OR A HEAD COACH. THIS SHOULD ELIMINATE A BUNCH OF APPLICANTS FROM JUCO AND POSITION COACHES AT EVERY LEVEL. TANNER STINES IS THE CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE.
My best guess is that we will have a coach by December 10. Thus, there will be a quick cutoff point for applications, and my guess a quick decision to the Final Three and then interviews. I do not see this as being 45 people apply and McNeese sets up 10 interviews by Skype. I am not privy to who is actually calling the shots; but as I mentioned earlier, Dr. Burckel is involved in athletic future planning and will have a say in this decision. I would bet he had a say in the decision to have an opening.
Instead of throwing out names which would only stir up more rumors, let me give my hope for the job. College and high school football is undergoing a great change from the previous era’s that everyone wants to point to. I am an advocate for a balanced defense, offense, and kicking game, but I am very aware of the shift in rules and direction the game is going.
My point is that we have to find a guy who can juice up the offense. The head coach can be a defensive specialist like Northwestern State’s Brad Laird, but you have to bring in an offensive guru who is staying ahead of the new curve that is developing. I am not so certain the Pokes may have to look at making some updates to the 4-2-5, or even going to a different scheme. I say that only because I see the trends nationally leaning to offense.
Teams like UIW and Rockwall spread 5 WRs out that force the linebackers to move out wider to protect slants, etc. It used to be that no OL could support a QB if five guys are spread. But defensive teams are being forced to spread out as well which eliminates a lot of the blitzing. In most cases it is 5 OLs blocking 4 DLs. You can blitz your linebackers, but those crossing routes are wide open. It is also more difficult to play zone or a cover two when offenses are so spread. When you have a Tua or Kyler Murray running an offense with no spy on the QB, they are going to kill you with their legs. Joe Burrow and Kellen Mond had plenty of rushing yards on Saturday.
This past weekend we had the #1 offense in the Big 10 going up against the #1 defense in the country statistically. Ohio State hung 62 points on this defense. We saw the highest paid defensive assistant in the country at LSU give up 31 points to a very average A&M team that has an excellent scheme as well as a great play caller. Both teams were tired I am sure, but it was also two OCs cooking up some pretty good plays in overtime.
I could go on and on and give examples of great offenses at Alabama, Clemson, Oklahoma, etc., but you just have to accept the fact that stats are not lying. The discussion on Monday on national radio was who would get in the playoffs between Ohio State and Oklahoma. The consensus was that both were super offenses with OU being maybe the best in the country . But they all agreed that their defenses cannot stop Clemson or Alabama. They just have to outscore them.
Why has this developed? It all begins with the year round high school development of quarterbacks that is going on. 7 on 7 in Texas has gotten so big that these summer offenses have carried over to the fall schemes. In 1999 I saw Garland whip Katy in the 5A state title game. We had 8 of our top 10 athletes on defense. We signed 7 off of defense and two off of offense. The coaches told me they wanted athletic linemen to be placed on defense, the slower more powerful guys on the offensive line. The three top middle school quarterbacks went to the defensive backfield; we kept two 5’10 field generals for QB. We won state by running 90% of the time out of a wing-tee power offense and playing great defense.
We advanced 19 years and I watched a very talented Allen team play a very talented Rockwall team last Friday and it was 35-33 at half. There was not one punt the entire game. These coaches put their best athletes on offense and dare you to stop them. Allen has good players on defense as well, but these 4 and 5 star WRs around the state just wear out the typical 4.6 to 4.7 corner. So high school has changed the way the college coaches think.
The Clemson quarterback is one year out of high school and the guy looks like he could play in the NFL right now. They are going to camps every weekend in the summer and they are fantastic passers.
When you factor in the rule changes that help the offense, and the 7 on 7 development of skilled players, you have an imbalance in competition. It may not be that way in every state because some states are still 10 years behind. In the 1960’s and 1970’s Louisiana was producing more quarterbacks than any state in the union. It all started in Shreveport with the progressive schemes that Woodlawn’s A.L Williams had developed. At one point in the 1970’s, Texas did not have one single quarterback in the NFL while Louisiana had 9. For whatever reason, the NFL was not signing wishbone quarterbacks.
Schemes change from decade to decade. You have to be able to score in 2018-2019. I just marvel at what the UIW, HBU, and ACU coaches have done with less recruited players, but with players who fit a certain system. Coaches at any level who refuse to change with the times are often passed by. Defenses over the years were built to stop the “I” formation, the two back veer system, the pro set, etc., but these offensive minds never rest. There is only so much you can do on defense and remain sound. But these enemies of the defense are drawing up routes that take advantage of every rule there is. I have seen more screens and picks in football this year than what I see at a college basketball game.
Rockwall and Allen both had TE’s who were 6’4 or better that lined up everywhere. Their top WRs were 6′ to 6’3. So the poor defensive coordinators were matching up 5’9 to 5’10 DB’s against these guys. Good luck when you are trying to convince your head coach that you want the 6’3 4.5 guy as your safety and you want the 6′ 4.4 guy as your corner. Even at Barbe I bet they go to offense.
So it is my opinion that our next coach can be either a former DC or a former OC, but he needs to hire the very best person to offset his weaknesses. I really don’t care what they run scheme wise as long as they fill in the slots with players who can run that system. Both ACU , HBU, and UIW found undersized quarterbacks who played in the exact style of Air Raid type of offense in high school and were smart guys who could follow the coach’s transcript.
LSU VS A&M POST GAME FIGHT
I may have jumped the gun in putting all the blame on the Aggie student manager Cole Fisher. New video shows that Fisher was pushing Coach Craig of A&M away from the LSU bench while he was running his mouth. Coach Kragthorpe is shown going after Craig in which Fisher turned and shoved him in the chest. It was reported that he punched him and caused a head injury. Now it makes sense that a pacemaker on Coach K may have been affected.
It was after this shove to Coach K that LSU coach Kevin Faulk swung at Cole Fisher. Then after Fisher was shouting a LSU player(Battle) came in and threw a hook to Fisher. Jimbo said both he and Orgeron are watching video and working with their administration to figure all of this out.